What Are the Best Practices for Disciplining Employees with Mental Health Issues in a Supportive and Non-Discriminatory Way?

Mental health challenges are not always visible, yet they can profoundly impact an employee’s performance, engagement, and overall wellbeing. As mental health awareness grows, employers are becoming increasingly mindful of the unique challenges employees face when dealing with mental health issues. Disciplining employees with mental health concerns requires a thoughtful, supportive, and empathetic approach to ensure fairness and avoid discrimination.

In this article, we will explore best practices for disciplining employees with mental health issues in a way that supports their wellbeing while maintaining a productive and supportive work environment. At Wellbeing Tribez, we believe that understanding and addressing mental health concerns are essential to building a healthier, more inclusive workplace.

1. What Are the Common Mental Health Issues Employees Face at Work?

Mental health issues are diverse and affect employees in various ways. Here are some of the most common conditions that may impact job performance:

• Anxiety: Employees experiencing anxiety disorders may struggle with excessive worry, restlessness, and difficulty focusing. This may hinder their capacity to meet deadlines and collaborate effectively with their colleagues.
• Depression: Those with depression may feel persistent sadness, lack of motivation, and low energy, making it difficult to perform work tasks and maintain workplace relationships.
• Burnout: Often a result of prolonged stress, burnout leads to physical and emotional exhaustion, which can cause decreased productivity and morale.
• Stress-related disorders: Stress can lead to physical symptoms such as headaches and insomnia, which can affect an employee’s ability to perform well under pressure.
• Fact: Mental health conditions, including anxiety and depression, significantly impact workplace productivity. In fact, the global economy loses approximately $1 trillion annually due to lost productivity from mental health problems. (WHO)

Recognising these conditions is vital for fostering a supportive workplace where employees feel understood and not penalised for their struggles.

2. Why Is It Important to Recognise Mental Health Challenges When Disciplining Employees?

Disciplining employees with mental health issues requires more than simply assessing job performance. Understanding the underlying mental health challenges is crucial for ensuring fairness and compassion.

• Impact on performance: Employees dealing with mental health issues may have trouble concentrating, making decisions, or organising their tasks, resulting in lower productivity and performance. These challenges are often beyond the employee’s control, and penalising them for this can exacerbate their condition.
• Legal and ethical considerations: Failing to recognise mental health concerns could lead to legal risks. Many countries have regulations protecting employees with mental health conditions from discrimination. Employers must ensure that they are not violating these laws by treating mental health-related performance issues the same as those not related to mental health.
• Fact: For example, a well-known case involving the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) revealed that a company paid $250,000 after wrongfully terminating an employee with depression, despite receiving a doctor’s note. This case underscores the legal and ethical need for employers to address mental health challenges fairly and compassionately.
• Cultural sensitivity: It’s crucial to address mental health with empathy, particularly when working with Black employees or other marginalised groups, where mental health stigma may be more pronounced. A culturally sensitive approach ensures a supportive and inclusive environment for everyone.

Workplace mental health challenges are becoming increasingly common, with 76% of U.S. workers reporting symptoms of a mental health condition. As a result, more employers are acknowledging the importance of taking proactive measures. (HHS.Gov)

Read more: What is Mental Wellbeing Definition? Why It’s Essential for a Healthy Life

3. How Can Employers Create a Supportive Environment for Employees with Mental Health Issues?

Creating a supportive, non-discriminatory environment is foundational to maintaining a healthy and productive workplace. Here’s how employers can cultivate such an environment:

• Promote open communication: Promote open communication, allowing employees to express their mental health challenges without the fear of stigma. When employees feel safe discussing their struggles, it allows for early intervention and the provision of necessary accommodations.
• Training and awareness: Offer mental health training for managers and employees. Equip them with the tools to recognise the signs of mental distress and engage in supportive conversations with affected employees.
• Develop an inclusive culture: Foster a workplace culture that values diversity and inclusivity. Supportively addressing mental health challenges helps reduce stigma and creates a more cohesive team.
• Fact: Nearly half of U.S. workers report concerns about disclosing mental health issues in the workplace, fearing judgment or job loss. However, workplaces that prioritise mental health by offering training and reducing stigma see improved morale and productivity. For instance, the NHS reported that nearly 32.5 million sick days were taken over the past four years due to mental health concerns like anxiety and depression. (The Times)

At Wellbeing Tribez, we focus on providing culturally relevant resources to ensure the mental health needs of Black communities are met in the workplace,Ensuring that every individual, irrespective of their background, receive the support they deserve.

Read more: Expert Consultancy Services for Health and Community

4. What Are the Best Approaches for Disciplining Employees with Mental Health Issues?

Disciplining employees with mental health concerns doesn’t mean bypassing performance expectations. However, it does mean adopting more compassionate and flexible approaches:

• Performance improvement plans: Rather than jumping straight to disciplinary measures, develop a performance improvement plan (PIP) that considers the employee’s mental health challenges. The PIP should focus on achievable goals, provide additional support, and clearly outline the steps needed to meet expectations.
• Open, transparent conversations: Ensure that employees understand what is expected of them and why. Approach these conversations with empathy, explaining that the company is committed to supporting them through their struggles while maintaining productivity standards.
• Foster mutual understanding: It’s essential to keep the lines of communication open. Regular meetings with employees to discuss their progress, obstacles, and wellbeing are key to cultivating trust and fostering a deeper understanding.
• Fact: A study from the World Health Organisation suggests that providing reasonable accommodations, such as flexible work schedules, can reduce absenteeism and increase employee satisfaction. In one instance, the Australian National University faced legal challenges after mismanaging an employee’s disciplinary process related to mental health, highlighting the importance of fair and supportive disciplinary practices. (
  

Wellbeing Tribez offers resources such as life coaching services and mental wellness support to help employees manage their mental health while striving to meet their professional goals.

Read more:

5. How Can Employers Offer Reasonable Accommodations to Support Employees’ Mental Health?

One of the most effective ways to support employees with mental health challenges is by offering reasonable accommodations. These accommodations allow employees to maintain their performance while addressing their mental health needs:

• Flexible work schedules: Offering employees the option to adjust their schedules or offering remote work options can help them manage symptoms like fatigue or anxiety.
• Job modifications: In some cases, job responsibilities must be adjusted to accommodate an employee’s condition. This could mean reassigning tasks or allowing breaks throughout the day.
• Access to support services: Provide employees with access to mental health services, including therapy or counselling, as well as wellness programs that focus on relaxation, stress management, and coping strategies.
• Fact: Research indicates that employees who are given accommodations like flexible schedules or adjusted responsibilities tend to perform better and experience reduced stress levels. For instance, companies offering mental health resources like counselling or wellness programs see reduced absenteeism and improved job satisfaction.

Wellbeing Tribez provides tailored support, including wellness coaching and social care services, ensuring employees receive the resources they need to thrive both personally and professionally.

6. What Are the Best Communication Strategies When Addressing Mental Health Issues with Employees?

Clear, compassionate communication is key when addressing mental health issues in the workplace:

• Active listening: Listen to the employee’s concerns without interruption. This shows empathy and helps build a connection based on mutual respect.
• Clear expectations: Outline job expectations clearly, but do so with an understanding of the employee’s challenges. This helps avoid confusion and anxiety about performance.
• Offer continuous support: Communication should not be a one-off event. Regular check-ins are vital for providing ongoing support and making any necessary adjustments to accommodations.
• Fact: Research indicates that clear communication and active listening during mental health-related discussions lead to improved performance. In fact, a report from Spill Chat notes that mental health problems are among the top factors leading to lower productivity in the workplace, but addressing them early through empathetic communication can significantly improve employee outcomes.

Encourage a dialogue that centres on both the employee’s needs and the company’s objectives. This creates a balanced and compassionate approach to discipline.

7. How Can Mental Health Training Help Managers and Employees?

Offering mental health training to managers and employees benefits the entire workplace. It helps everyone understand the importance of mental health, recognise signs of distress, and learn how to offer support:

• Awareness: Mental health training raises awareness of the signs and symptoms of mental health conditions, making it easier for managers to identify when an employee might need support.
• Support strategies: Training teaches employees and managers how to offer support and implement reasonable accommodations to help employees succeed in their roles.
• Reducing stigma: A workplace that actively provides mental health education reduces stigma, which in turn promotes a more inclusive environment for all employees.

We offer specialised mental health and wellbeing courses, equipping workplaces with the knowledge and skills needed to create supportive environments.

Conclusion

Disciplining employees with mental health issues requires careful consideration, compassion, and an understanding of their unique challenges. By implementing supportive practices and offering reasonable accommodations, employers can create a more inclusive and productive work environment.

At Wellbeing Tribez, we are committed to helping businesses foster healthier, more supportive workplace cultures by providing tailored services and resources. Whether through life coaching, mental wellness support, or educational tools, we empower both employees and employers to thrive together.

Take the first step toward building a workplace where mental health is prioritised. Reach out to Wellbeing Tribez today to explore how we can help you create a more supportive and productive environment for everyone.

FAQs

port, creating a healthier, more productive work environment.